5.4.14

The Football League vs The Scottish League - 1890s


Pikes Lane
The Football League was always on the lookout for sources of income generation. They identified the playing of representative matches as being a potentially lucrative venture as early as 1889. In March 1891 the FA refused the League [permission to play against the Scottish League, so the first representative match was played against The Alliance (line ups are here). The following year, however, the FA relented.

Football League
2
2
Scottish League
11.04.92 Pikes Lane, Bolton (9500)
McInnes, Bassett                                                                              Maley, Taylor

Reader*
(West Bromwich Albion)
McLeod**
(Dumbarton)
Holmes *
(Preston North  End)
Hannah**
(Renton)
Gow **
(Sunderland)
Doyle **
(Celtic)
Groves**
(West Bromwich Albion)
Maley**
(Celtic)
Gardiner ++
(Bolton Wanderers)
Doyle
(Dumbarton)
Reynolds*
(West Bromwich Albion)
McBride
(Renton)
Bassett *
(West Bromwich Albion)
Taylor **
(Dumbarton)
McInnes **
(Notts County)
McCallum **
(Celtic)
Goodall *
(Derby County)
McCall **
(Renton)
Chadwick *
(Everton)
McMahon  **
(Celtic)
Daft *
(Notts County)
Bell  **
(Dumbarton)

Maley scored whilst Bell put the custodian through... Contemporary press reports describe the common practice of taking the 'keeper out.
4 Scotsmen in the Football League team, 3 of them capped.
From here on the games took on a more International flavour- in fact the FA warned the Football League against billing these games as 'Internationals'- with the League only selecting Englishmen. The games were usually played a week or so after the England v Scotland international fixture and comparisons between the merits of the teams selected in each instance are often drawn in the contemporary press.

Scottish League
3
4
Football League
08.04.93 Celtic Park  (31500)                                                              
  Begbie (og), Geary, Wood,Bassett
Taylor, Madden , McMahon  
                                                                             
McLeod **
(Dumbarton)
Rowley *
(Stoke)
Adams **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Clare *
(Stoke)
Doyle **
(Celtic)
Howarth *
(Everton)
Begbie **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Reynolds*
(West Bromwich Albion)
Mitchell **
(Rangers)
Perry*
(West Bromwich Albion)
Kelly **
(Celtic)
Needham *
(Sheffield United)
Taylor **
(Dumbarton)
Bassett *
(West Bromwich Albion)
McCreadie **
(Rangers)
Geary *
(Everton)
Madden **
(Celtic)
Southworth *
(Blackburn Rovers)
McMahon **
(Celtic)
Wood *
(Wolverhampton Wdrs)
Campbell  **
(Celtic)
Schofield*
(Stoke)
Adams **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Clare *
(Stoke)


Football League
1
1
Scottish League
21.04.94 Goodison Park (28300)
Goodall                                                                            Oswald

Sutcliffe*
(Bolton Wanderers)
Haddow **
(Rangers)
Holmes*
(Preston North  End)
Adams **  
(Heart of Midlothian)
Crabtree*
(Burnley)
Doyle **  
(Celtic)
Reynolds*
(Aston Villa)
Begbie  **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Holt*
(Everton)
Mitchell **  
(Rangers)
Needham*
(Sheffield United)
Kelly **  
(Celtic)
Athersmith*
(Aston Villa)
Taylor **
(Dumbarton)
Goodall*
(Derby County)
Blessington **
(Celtic)
Devy*
(Aston Villa)
Oswald**
(St Bernard’s)
Wheldon*
(Small Heath)
McMahon **  
(Celtic)
Spikesley*
(The Wednesday)
Barker**
(Rangers)


Scottish League
1
4
Football League
13.04.95 Celtic Park (30000)
Madden                                                                         Devey, Becton (3)

McArthur**
(Celtic)
Storer
(Woolwich Arsenal)
Drummond**
(Rangers)
Crabtree*
(Burnley)
Doyle**
(Celtic)
Holmes *
(Preston North  End)
Marshall**
(Rangers)
Reynolds*
(Aston Villa)
Kelly **
(Celtic)
Langley
(The Wednesday)
Gibson**
(Rangers)
Needham*
(Sheffield United)
Taylor**
(St Mirren)
Athersmith *
(Aston Villa)
Madden**
(Celtic)
Becton*
(Liverpool)
Oswald**
(St Bernard’s)
Devey *
(Aston Villa)
McMahon**
(Celtic)
Hodgetts*
(Aston Villa)
Divers**
(Celtic)
Smith*
(Aston Villa)




Football League
5
1
Scottish League
11.04.96 Goodison Park (21280)
Devey, Athersmith, Becton (2), Goodall                                   Oswald

Sutcliffe*
(Bolton Wanderers)
McArthur**
(Celtic)
Spencer*
(Aston Villa)
Drummond**
(Rangers)
Williams*
(West Bromwich Albion)
Doyle **
(Celtic)
Perry*
(West Bromwich Albion)
Gibson**
(Rangers)
Higgins
(West Bromwich Albion)
Kelly **
(Celtic)
Crabtree*
(Aston Villa)
Hogg **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Devey *
(Aston Villa)
Madden**
(Celtic)
Athersmith *
(Aston Villa)
Blessington **
(Celtic)
Goodall *
(Derby County)
Oswald**
(St Bernard’s)
Becton*
(Liverpool)
King **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Millward*
(Everton)
Walker **
(Heart of Midlothian)


Scottish League
3
0
Football League
24.04.97 Ibrox (34650)
Low, McPherson (2)

McFarlane **
(Third Lanark)
Sutcliffe*
(Bolton Wanderers)
Smith**
(Rangers)
Spencer*
(Aston Villa)
Doyle**
(Celtic)
Williams*
(West Bromwich Albion)
Gibson**
(Rangers)
Crabtree*
(Aston Villa)
Russell**
(Celtic)
Crawshaw*
(The Wednesday)
Keillor**
(Dundee)
Needham*
(Sheffield United)
Low**
(Rangers)
Athersmith *
(Aston Villa)
McPherson **
(Rangers)
Bloomer *
(Derby County)
Millar**
(Rangers)
Devey  *
(Aston Villa)
King**
(Celtic)
Chadwick*
(Everton)
Walker**
(Heart of Midlothian)
Bradshaw*
(Liverpool)


Football League
1
2
Scottish League
09.04.98  Villa Park (22000)
Beats                                                                                 Hamilton (2)

Foulke *
(Sheffield United)
Dickie **
(Rangers)
Thickett*
(Sheffield United)
Smith**
(Rangers)
Langley
(The Wednesday)
Doyle **
(Celtic)
Perry*
(West Bromwich Albion)
Gibson**
(Rangers)
Needham*
(Sheffield United)
Breslin**
(Hibernian)
Morren*
(Sheffield United)
Marshall **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Athersmith *
(Aston Villa)
Gilhooley
(Celtic)
Wood*
(Wolverhampton Wndrs)
Millar**
(Rangers)
Beats*
(Wolverhampton Wndrs)
Hamilton**
(Rangers)
Wheldon*
(Aston Villa)
McPherson**
(Rangers)
Smith*
(Aston Villa)
Smith**
(Rangers)


Scottish League
1
4
Football League
01.04.99 Celtic Park (35000)
Campbell                                                              Athersmith (2), Bloomer, Setlle

McArthur **
(Celtic)
Hillman*
(Burnley)
Smith**  
(Rangers)
Prescott
(Notts County)
Storrier**
(Celtic)
Eccles
(Stoke)
Breslin**
(Hibernian)
Forman*
(Nottingham Forest)
Marshall **
(Heart of Midlothian)
Crawshaw*
(The Wednesday)
Gibson**
(Rangers)
Crabtree*
(Aston Villa)
Campbell**
(Rangers)
Athersmith*
(Aston Villa)
Walker**
(Heart of Midlothian)
Bloomer*
(Derby County)
Hamilton**  
(Rangers)
Toman
(Burnley)
McPherson**  
(Rangers)
Settle*
(Bury)
Bell **
(Celtic)
Turner
(Stoke)







Wins
Goals
Football League
 4
 21
Scottish League
 2
 14
Drawn
 2




   *English International                                             
** Scottish International 
++ Scottish, not capped (FL only)